Police Brutality / Individual record

Melvin Sylvester

Melvin Sylvester, 65, died on 2003-08-08 in New York City, NY, after an encounter with City of New York Police Department.

Record ID
PB-7742
Incident date
August 8, 2003
Date of death
August 8, 2003
Outcome
Fatal
Location
New York City, NY
Agency
City of New York Police Department
Category
Police shooting
Age (reported)
65

What happened

A family feud between neighbors at the St. Nicholas Houses in Harlem developed into a confrontation between 65-year-old Sylvester, holding a six-inch knife and reportedly intoxicated, and an undercover vice cop, who fatally shot Sylvester when he refused to drop the weapon. Fatal Encounters, the national database of deaths involving police compiled by journalist D. Brian Burghart, records the highest level of force as: Gunshot.

Investigation & findings

No outcome has been reported.

Fatal Encounters database (D. Brian Burghart), 2000–2021

Source record details
Race code in source
African-American/Black
Race source method
Fatal Encounters race field (not imputed)
Gender (source)
male

Last reviewed: November 21, 2026

Sources & records

  1. Reporting by nydailynews.comnydailynews.com
  2. Reporting by fatalencounters.orgfatalencounters.org
  3. Methodology and national police killings trackingMapping Police Violence · Dataset/methodology
  4. U.S. Police Violence in 2025: Year-end ReportCampaign Zero / Mapping Police Violence · 2026-02 · Dataset report
  5. List of killings by law enforcement officers in the United States (monthly lists, January 2025 to November 2026)Wikipedia · 2026 · Reference list
  6. List of unarmed African Americans killed by law enforcement officers in the United StatesWikipedia · 2026 · Reference list