Police Brutality / Individual record

John Eric Henderson

John Eric Henderson, 32, was shot by Officer Christopher Gaynor during a traffic stop in Chattanooga on May 29, 2003. Henderson was holding a bottle of cologne, which Gaynor mistook for a weapon.

Record ID
PB-2603
Incident date
May 29, 2003
Outcome
Fatal
Location
Chattanooga, TN
Agency
Chattanooga Police Department
Category
Police shooting
Age (reported)
32

What happened

John Eric Henderson, 32, was fatally shot during a traffic stop in Chattanooga on May 29, 2003. Officer Christopher Gaynor testified that Henderson went to his car and reached for a brown object; Gaynor said he mistook it for a gun and fired. He later identified the object as a bottle of cologne.

At Gaynor’s trial, a defense expert testified that the officer acted appropriately, while a Chattanooga Police Department Internal Affairs witness testified that Gaynor used excessive force. Rainbow PUSH’s Chattanooga chapter criticized the acquittal and described Henderson as an unarmed man.

Investigation & findings

Gaynor was charged with criminally negligent homicide; his first trial ended in a mistrial, and a jury acquitted him at the second trial. The article reported that Gaynor had been fired after the shooting; it also reported that an Internal Affairs witness said he used excessive force.

Wikipedia: List of unarmed African Americans killed by law enforcement officers in the United States, CC BY-SA

Source record details
Race code in source
B
Race source method
Wikipedia list (race as reported in cited sources)
Gender (source)
male
Armed status (source)
unarmed

Last reviewed: November 19, 2026

Sources & records

  1. Reporting by chattanoogan.comchattanoogan.com
  2. Encyclopedia entryWikipedia
  3. Methodology and national police killings trackingMapping Police Violence · Dataset/methodology
  4. U.S. Police Violence in 2025: Year-end ReportCampaign Zero / Mapping Police Violence · 2026-02 · Dataset report
  5. List of killings by law enforcement officers in the United States (monthly lists, January 2025 to November 2026)Wikipedia · 2026 · Reference list