ICE Brutality / Individual record

Caillagua

A federal judge ruled that ICE was illegally holding Caillagua without a bond hearing under its mandatory-detention policy.

Record ID
IB-16157
Incident date
July 8, 2026
Outcome
Nonfatal
Location
New York
Category
Detention ruled unlawful

What happened

A federal judge ruled that ICE was illegally holding Caillagua without a bond hearing under its mandatory-detention policy. Judge Lawrence J. Vilardo of the U.S. District Court for the Western District of New York ruled for the detainee on 2026-07-08 in case 1:26-cv-01315 (Caillagua v. FCI Berlin, Warden). It is one of more than 22,000 rulings against ICE's detention practices that POLITICO has tracked since ICE began locking up long-time residents without bond in July 2025. Many detainees are identified in court records by surname only.

Investigation & findings

Ruled unlawful: mandatory detention without a bond hearing rejected. Strength: ruled illegal by a court.

Last reviewed: November 20, 2026

Sources & records

  1. Reporting by courtlistener.comcourtlistener.com
  2. Reporting by politico.compolitico.com
  3. Detainee Death ReportingUS Immigration and Customs Enforcement · Official death reporting
  4. Deaths and Health Care Issues in ICE Detention CentersKFF · 2026 · Research analysis
  5. Mortality in US Immigration and Customs Enforcement DetentionJAMA · 2026 · Peer reviewed analysis
  6. List of shootings by U.S. immigration agents in the second Trump administrationWikipedia · 2026 · Reference list